Monday, December 21, 2015

Over Sea, Under Stone, Chapter 12

Or: What Barney Did When Simon and Jane Weren't at the Rendezvous Point.

Barney did not find Merry on the path up the headland—which makes sense, since Merry's off to Turuo on Mrs. Palk's false information.

Returning the corner where they are meant to meet, Barney quickly surmises that the others are absent because they're still following Mrs. Palk. He decides to join them. Recalling Mrs. Palk's excitement for the carnival and dancing, he falls in with the procession when it passes by.

The people in the procession are apparently all dressed up in costumes: trees, and sailors, and jesters, and animals... and racist caricatures (remember Mrs. Palk's “Red Indian” feathered headdress? Yeah, that's not just an allusion). Barney goes into the middle of the dance, and gets a glimpse of Mrs. Palk, right before he's literally carried away by a person dressed as a cat and a man in “sheik” robes.

I'm wagering the cat is none other than Polly Withers, and that her brother is the other.

And somehow, no one notices two costumed people manhandling a kicking and screaming boy out of the festival and into a car. They do trap and gag him with the robes, but this still seems like something that someone in this huge crowd should notice and express concern at.

Meanwhile, Jane and Simon, apparently failing to locate Mrs. Palk, have checked the house and the rendezvous corner, and have found no sign of Barney. They decide he must have found Merry on the headland, and head there.

Back with Barney in the car, he has identified his kidnappers by their voices. Yes, it's the Withers. And Norman Withers is in blackface, if you needed another reason to dislike him. Arriving at their destination, the Withers' disentangle Barney from the robes and resume their earlier seeming friendliness—inviting him in for tea and saying they just want to introduce him to a friend. The gas-lighting almost seems to work, as Barney starts wonder if it's just a festive joke, and that they really are nice, and the kids have just misjudged them. Bill Hoover's appearance reminds Barney of the chase and Polly demanding the map, and this time the abrupt shift really feels intentional: like Barney just broke some sort of enchantment that made him view people from “the dark” as favorably as possible. It would explain everyone's strange trust in Mrs. Palk... Or maybe “the dark” is just good at abusing with people's tendency to not assume malice.

Barney is brought into the presence of a deep-voiced person whom the others seem to defer to. He identifies himself as Mr. Hastings. They have sandwiches brought in, and Barney finds his surroundings fairly familiar: they remind him, somehow, of the Grey House. Mr. Hastings is interested and wants to know more.

Current guess: they're either at Bill Hoover's dad's house or the vicarage Jane ended up at earlier.

Hastings suddenly asks, “Is it buried under the Grey House, Barnabas, or one of the standing stones?” Barney chokes from surprise and pretends not to understand. I'm reminded of Polly Withers' sudden, direct questions, and I wonder if this is a standard strategy of their side.

It's somewhat odd to be asking that, however, because Hastings immediately launches into a villains' premature reveal, insisting that they already know everything, and that he's been brought here in order to “put a stop to your little quest”. Perhaps he knows less that he pretends and is fishing for more information? They're right on the kids finding a map and having Professor Lyon aka Great-Uncle Merry helping them, but nothing specific has been said about a grail, or its location.

[And if it was under the Grey House, why would the kids be taking the map up to headland? Shouldn't there presence there be a big clue to the opponents that the standing stones are more likely, since that's the one place the kids keep returning to?]

Barney continues to feign ignorance, and asks for another sandwich. Mr. Withers is dismissed on some errand (“you know what you have to do”), and Barney asks Hastings why the others address him as “sir”. Hastings knows that Barney is bluffing, and tries to put in a pitch for his side of things. It doesn't look good, as this involves more attempted gas-lighting rather than a straight-forward explanation of his opinions. There's also a lot of casting suspicion on Merry, and Hastings has the gall to suggest that he (Hastings) is clearly not evil, because he hasn't harmed Barney and even gave him food! There was no kidnapping, just a little joke, and it's was Polly's doing, anyway. Merry's really out for his own fame and is using the kids, etc.

Good grief. As much as Merry's light vs. dark explanation involved little solid evidence that the other side is, in fact, evil, the way the dark treats people has me decidedly opposed to them. So far, we've seen them pretend to be nice, then make demands; lie, directly and intentionally; make people doubt their own experience (gas-lighting); and then blame other people for what they can't explain away. They are also possibly are using magic or some other kind of psychic influence to make people disregard their harmful or frightening actions.

Hastings also tries the “I will tell you everything” gambit, offering to make everything clear if Barney will admit to seeing the map. Instead of explaining, however, he basically just argues that Merry is looking for selfish reasons, while he [Hastings] and his people want to make the information available to everyone. Barney almost slips, but manages to avoid naming the grail as the object of the map. When he answers Hastings' rhetorical question about Merry's motivation being “In the name of King Arthur, and of the old world before the dark came”, things manage to get even creepier, and Hastings gives orders to move out.

“Where are you taking me?” [Barney asked].

“You are coming with us to the sea,” said the voice behind the dark intent eyes. “You will cause no more trouble, and you will do whatever I say. And when we are on the sea, Barnabas, you are going to tell us about your map, and show us where it leads.”

And on that happy note, the chapter ends. I'm 90% sure at this point that Hastings can cast the imperius curse as a free action once per round.

No comments:

Post a Comment